Friday, March 25, 2011

Environmental Isolate

Two Views Of One

In reading the news of the past week
I came upon a fundamentally surprising
article suggesting the Bible's organizers,
over the years, edited out mention of
Asherah, whom the Book of Kings and
other sources suggest was worshiped
alongside Yahweh, in his temple, as his
wife.

The comments following on the article
were heated beyond the usual urgency
that drives people to contribute. As one
can imagine, there were those eager to
discredit (God is neither he nor she; it
is our language that uses pronouns), as
well as those eager to see vindication
(at last, we're finally appreciating our
Queen).

Let's just say I think both perspectives
are right. And here's an example of why:

As I read on, I came upon an article about
a well-intentioned group called the
Archangel Ancient Tree Archive whose love
for ancient trees has led them to clone the
mightiest specimens still living on earth
(think towering redwoods and sequoias)
and to plant these clones hither and yon,
hoping they will succeed in growing to the
size of their clone-sakes.

The AATA is probably going about their
work with a minimum of smarts; they probably
aren't planting their clones in unsuitable climes.
But they are ignoring Ashera; essentially,
they're growing environmental isolates. One
has only to look at secondary forests growing
on land that once saw wilderness in all it's glory.
After the old growth is cut down, decades of
rain leach the soil of nutrients; the complex
web of life, involving animals, fungi, microbes
and temperature modulation are swept away
and often a monoculture is then planted instead.
Such second-generation trees are guaranteed
to be compromised in stature.

This is why wilderness is so valuable. It is not
just isolated champions standing tall, proving
themselves superior and able to pass on genetic
success; it is the nurturing entirety of the dead
and the living, creating the fertile soil and
enveloping circumstance that enable greatness.



Sunday, March 6, 2011

My Conservative Hat On

Roots Rock Conservative

Nobody can outdo me as a Conservative. No really, I'm serious. This may sound odd, coming from a voice that is normally Liberal, but the secret to Conservatism is that its ends are often best brought about by Liberalism.

Take, for example, the current Tea Party effort to defund Planned Parenthood, Head Start and WIC (nutritional assistance for new mothers). Take away the support for Planned Parenthood, for example, and what do you get?
* More abortions, as low-income parents make 'mistakes', then 'correct' them.
* More of a need for healthcare, as low-income mothers miss out on simple, preventive medical attention.
* More babies born into poverty, thus adding to the burden of the welfare state.
* Probably, a slight increase in unloved babies, meaning more delinquency, crime, etc.; dysfunction in general.

It's intuitive, and also a studied fact, that spending on mothers and newborns returns an initial investment manyfold.

Interestingly, the single most predictive factor in the academic success of a child is the level of schooling reached by the mother. No matter how hard teachers and a school system may try, a child's intellectual trajectory is all but decided by the age of three. Which would seem to suggest that if a Conservative like myself really wants fellow citizens who are well-adjusted, peaceable and productive, perhaps the most likely prescription is an increased investment in mothers and infants.

And I do just that. Planned Parenthood is a group that I've donated to out of each paycheck (thanks, United Way) since 2002. But the real problems among us aren't going to be solved with drops in the bucket like mine; there are simply too many needs for that. And so we have programs like Head Start.

As for the Tea Partiers' good intentions, they and most Americans would agree that financing something like 40% of a nation's budget with borrowing is just plain wrong. Except that a large majority of that 40% (something like two-thirds) is our paying for Unemployment Insurance, Medicaid, etc., as large numbers of workers are out of work, and the fact that tax revenues decline with an economic slide. So, as most economists will attest, getting the economy on a sound foundation is step one; a first step that will erase about half of the problem. Then come cut-backs. Otherwise, there is the very real danger of economic free-fall, when businesses opt not to invest, because nobody has the money to buy; a tailspin of unchecked depression that is a Conservative's worst nightmare.

Update (June 13th, '11):
A Head Start Fan
Kevin Drum at Mother Jones links to a recent study published in Science that shows, statistically, what we get for investing in Head Start. Drum estimates that for roughly $15 a year we could provide Head Start to 25% of the 3- and 4-year-olds in this country; those who would most benefit from it; this would be 25% of those who aren't already enrolled.

The study followed mainly black Chicagoans born around 1980, tracking them up until a few years ago.

And what would we get? From the charts it looks like a significant improvement in high school graduation rates, for one, from 65% to 85%, for example, among those whose mothers didn't graduate from high school. Improvements are also found for crime and drug abuse prevention.

An interesting sidenote: almost all the improvements between those who attended Head Start and among those who didn't came from males.

http://motherjones.com/kevin-drum/2011/06/building-better-kids-its-preschools-stupid


Saturday, February 12, 2011

The Wrong-headed Fall Silent

Happy Lincoln's Birthday All

Abraham Lincoln
His hand and pen;
He will be good but
God knows when.
-- A. Lincoln, age 16

Reading the 'Comments' section of the New York Times'
150th anniversary coverage of the Civil War today, I
came across a few dissenting voices. Someone felt
every effort should have been made to entice southern
secessionist states to return to the Union, as opposed
to Lincoln using immediate military force. Another
writer felt the President was a military incompetent.
Subsequent commenters noted how ill-informed these
views were.

Which brings up the question: what's to be said when
people are obviously wrong? There's no great glory in
showing others the error of their ways--in fact, it can
sometimes be counter-productive. Ideally, then, the
ignorant are best ignored and allowed to make their
way around, and effectively leave behind their mess.

But what about ignorance that bites? I also read today
at the Washington Monthly's Political Animal blog
that Republican leaders and their supporters in the press
seized on testimony before Congress which pointed to
"a reduction of 800,000 workers" by the year 2021
owing to the implementation of Health Care Reform.

Unfortunately, the howlers who sent this factoid ricocheting
around the internet didn't care about the context. When
one operates on a 'by any means necessary' basis, there
are no principles of even-handedness and dispassionate
inquiry to be lost; all is consumed in a flame-throwing
warfare of destruction. So, the fact that the 'reduction'
of 800,000 workers referenced older workers who feel they
can't retire, since they would lose their health care benefits,
was twisted into yet another unemployment statistic. When
in fact, if older workers feel they can retire without worry,
this will free up 800,000 jobs for younger workers; precisely
the opposite conclusion.

Are such gaffes to be ignored?

Sunday, January 16, 2011

Discovering The Next Big One

My One Cent

The stamped letter, telegraph, telephone, phonograph, radio, television, computer. In hindsight it all seems so obvious. In fact it's tempting to think that given enough meditating, the next big thing would be equally obvious. ESP cognition?

You could follow this same mental exercise within the domain of computers. The internet, e-mail, e-bay, google, craig's list, facebook, u-tube, twitter. Surely we're in the early, creative years of a communication medium that will eventually become saturated and simply turn out imitative formats with a slight twist. So what's next? Maybe something like Kickstarter crossed with American Idol and the Lottery. Call it 'Time Out'. If you win you get a year's income to follow your bliss. Each week's votes are rolled over into the next and there is no entry fee. 26 winners a year would require advertising income of $1.3 million a year to generate $50,000 every two weeks. You'd get a dozen or two entries to vote on, if you visited the Time Out site. To register, you'd receive a pin number mailed to your address, one per address.

Seriously, nobody knows what the next big thing will be. What we may know, though, depending on our degree of optimism regarding the future course of humankind, is that certain content found in any given format will be judged differently in the future.

If it's true that the human condition is advancing faster and faster, then yesteryear's dead ends, slavery, for example--which took centuries to overcome, will be tossed aside in much shorter time periods. So, websites that champion exploitation of reality, in bad faith, should eventually wither away. Of course there are complications, like the fact that an institution such as slavery is different than three dozen diehards supporting a website that extols cruelty towards misfits. And there's the profit motive in many cases. But in general a trend line is discernible.

Perhaps a few contours are identifiable:

* Genuine, organic experience will gradually supplant artifice
* Kindness and thoughtfulness will make headway
* Tribalism will tend to give way to a more universal outlook
* Appropriateness will win out over random need
* Happiness will tend to be found in accomplishment rather than in consumption
* Freedom will be enshrined in ever more ways

I am optimistic, I have to admit.


Saturday, December 4, 2010

The Single and The Many

X-Rayed: Politics

We use the elephant and the donkey as political party icons; but are they really that descriptive? Elephants are members of herds, while Republicans are individualists. Donkeys are stubborn, while Democrats are often conciliatory. What gives?

A more perfect fit for Republicans would be the lion, taking no guff and looking out for number one. And the Democrats? How about the zebra? A mix of color, with all equally endowed.

All of which makes one wonder what else is off-base with American politics. Do we really understand what makes us tick? Herewith something of a guess.

The body politic takes its cue from the geography of the human brain. Our brains have two hemispheres, one focused on logic and measurement, the other on a big-picture, emotional understanding.

Ah, but wait, you'll say, Republicans may be the party of the 'Right', but they prefer to 'feel' with their 'gut'. Likewise, Democrats may be the party of the 'Left', but they use 'egghead' solutions. This, even though 'Right' is all about cold, hard facts and mathematical proof, while 'Left' is the realm of our sixth sense. What's going on?

The explanation is simple. Each political party tends to be deficient in the other party's strong suit. Their failings (a president's reliance on his 'gut' for guidance; the imposition of a bureaucratic solution in lieu of personal responsibility) are all too telling.

To better understand where each side is coming from, let's look at the main source of inspiration for each:

*Republican: If you start with the
understanding that objectively, some
members of society are measurably
greater than others (whether leaders
in financial, social or intellectual terms),
they must be allowed to flourish in order
for society to do well. So, freedom is key.

*Democratic: If, on the other hand, you
begin with subjectivity, each member of
society wants to be recognized and allowed
to reach their potential. This requires an
inclusive message. The key here then is
equality.

We thus have freedom of the one contrasted with equality among the many.

Examples of politicians failing spectacularly at integrating the strengths of the other party are legendary. It could be argued, for example, that the Republican message of late has abandoned any pretense at visionary, bring-us-together reach; instead, using a term like 'the real America' divides us into 'us' and 'them'. Likewise, it could be said that the Democrats struck gold with Bill Clinton's welfare reform legislation, because it addressed their biggest perceived weakness: that they enable dependency.

In that vein, what would advance each party's electability, if their respective leadership could apply this analysis to their own party's direction?

For the Republicans, the way ahead is daunting. Not only should they reach out to incorporate elements of the other side's message ('home ownership for everybody'), more importantly, they should reconnect with their own philosophy. Frankly, the modern Republican party has lost its way. Their recent attempts at big-picture vision have relied on simplistic slogans, rather than careful consideration (tax cuts are always good; government regulation is always bad). This has, unfortunately, led the party into the hands of half-baked intellects (the abandonment of science for 'creationism'), which strikes at the heart of a party appealing to individual common sense experience.

For the Democrats, the path forward is much less problematic. Beginning with their core principals of equality and diversity they have embraced reason and the careful calibration of the logical mind. This has meant that wishful thinking in their own party has for the most part been abandoned. Critical examination, for example, revealed the pitfalls of 'socialist' approaches to effecting equality; thus, calls for a guaranteed income for all, that were heard in the '70s, are no more. To cite another example, instead of a hard or soft approach to crime, invariably, Ds should turn to what has been shown to work: in the case of crime, prevention and retraining.

More specifically, the Republican party would do well to ground itself in honesty, scientific understanding and fair-mindedness before it can expect to play anything but the role of spoiler.

The Democrats, on the other hand, should involve and educate their constituents. For the more each issue's specifics are aired and solutions underlined with logic and proof, the more likely flippant attack ads can be ignored.

Of course this is all assuming that a political party should simply follow the most popular way forward; and yet that is rarely where the country should go.


Thursday, November 11, 2010

All Together Now ...

What's Up With The Whig -- 'Official' edition

Yesterday's Herald-Whig splashed a story across the front page suggesting that "officials" thought the Federal Reserve's Quantitative Easing, or Q.E.--which will see $600 billion printed over the next half a year to buy Treasury bonds--was meant to weaken the dollar, and that this is why gas prices have seen a double digit rise.

The 'official' cited was the head of the Illinois AAA. Hmmm, sounds more like an orchestrated 'talking point'.

First, let's review why the Fed is engaging in Q.E. When our economy gets into a funk, it's as if everyone is waiting for everyone else to get out on the dance floor, but not wanting to be the only one out there. The federal government usually steps in and announces over the PA system that it will be offering refreshments in the middle of the dance floor. Usually, this gets people moving. Another option is for the Federal Reserve to likewise announce that it will be offering dance lessons--not nearly as welcome, but usually enough to get a few feet moving.

Critics of having the federal government involved through the 'stimulus' of refreshments say that Uncle Same offers overly expensive refreshments. Why not just let the dance happen? This is a curious argument. Surprisingly, it relies on an almost Communist altruism to do something for the greater good that no individual would otherwise do. Why be the first one to walk out on the dance floor when it's much easier to wait for others to head out there? It's simply not in your best interests to do the right thing.

The effect of no government involvement is for the economy to wait...and wait...and wait for a war or some other reason to get cranked up, meaning that we all sit on the sidelines when we could be out there dancing to full employment.

And what's the best way to have a strong economy when we're in a recession with high unemployment? Government stimulus. That's because business has no reason to hire and the unemployed can't afford to buy when money is scarce. So, the government, using the PA system, is the only one who can say "Ok, I'm counting to three, and everybody take a step out there." This can only happen, though, if there is a political consensus to do so. Unfortunately, Republicans are more interested in proving their economic theories are superior and so have time and again filibustered an adequate stimulus.

And the second best way for the government to respond? Have the Fed lower interest rates. In our current situation, though, that is of course not possible since rates are already up against 0%.

And the third best way? Print money. Normally, this could be a gateway to inflation, but in a time of low interest rates, the great danger from a recession is that deflation will occur, resulting in businesses sitting on the sidelines, waiting for prices to fall even further. Unemployment simply gets worse...and worse...and worse. When that happens, or if inflation falls to close to 0%, there's a need for more money in the economy, especially if the economic downturn was caused by a run on banks (failed banks are exhibit A in both the 1929 Great Depression and the 2008 Great Recession).

That then explains why the government is printing money. So, what's this about intentionally devaluing the dollar? It's true that a weaker dollar can be an effect of getting the economy going again, but it isn't what the Fed is trying to do. Whether the dollar is trading at 100 or 98 Chinese Yuan--or whatever the exchange rate is--is secondary to getting our economy functioning at near peak capacity.

Is the Herald-Whig intentionally harping on the increase in the price of gas? Is this a sign of it pandering to the no-doubt popular notion of government over-reach? I prefer to think it's a simple ignorance of macro-economic policy.

Wednesday, November 3, 2010

Gentleman's Honor

What Would Buddha Do?

It's a remarkable fact that President Obama rarely seems angry. In fact, the only time I can remember him blaming political opponents was when he was joking--and even then, it wasn't personal. Instead, he merely describes his difficulties as taking office in difficult circumstances, or having to get to work digging ourselves out of a hole. No accusatory tone, no name-calling, no finger-pointing, nothing but a focus on the future.

Given the circumstances he faces, that's amazing. The Republican Senate minority leader, for instance, has said:

"The single most important thing we want to achieve is for President Obama to be a one-term president."

And does that out-rank doing what's good for the country? Apparently so. For the past two years, and presumably for the next two, the minority leader has flouted senatorial procedure to intentionally slow the legislative branch to a crawl, has collaborated in holding up government appointments and in general acted in bad faith.

If President Obama's disciplined calm weren't genuine, though, he'd occasionally crack, as his opponents got under his skin. But no....

Nor do I expect him to tout his reserve. That, too, would go against character.

But surely a pundit or vocal voter will eventually notice, that at least at the White House, the tone in Washington has indeed changed.